. Please check your email to find a confirmation email, and follow the steps to confirm your humanity. Its time to play another game of What if with DC Comics history, but before we get into what could have happened, lets start at what actually did happen in The Dark Knight. Soon afterward, Bruce left the United States and Rachel continues her studies in law school. Batman has friends, and peers like Nightwing, Robin, Batgirl, Batwoman, and so on, who are his equals on just about every count. Sinceplaying Rachel Dawes, Gyllenhaal has starred inAway We Go, River of Fundament, White House Downand the British cult film Frank. The gambit itself is really part of the bigger thesis The Dark Knight tries to lay out: That one man trying to save a city whether he wears a mask or does it in broad daylight is an inherently impossible task. Which is why were going to open that decision to further discussion, through the poll below. He then sedates her and has his butler, Alfred Pennyworth (Michael Caine), take her home. The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. A number of things change in the months following the Siege of Gotham. Oh, and every day he doesn't, people will die, starting tonight. Ultimately the answer to "why wasn't Katie Holmes in The Dark Knight?" The gambit itself is really part of the bigger thesis The Dark Knight tries to lay out: That one man trying to save a city whether he wears a mask or does it in broad daylight is an . When the Joker shows up in Dent's hospital room, there to recover from burns he received the night of Rachel's death, we have no idea what the Joker is doing. Unfortunately, it doesnt hold up under much scrutiny. [1] She was named interim District Attorney.[4]. The Joker has kidnapped both Dent and Rachel and set them both to blow so that Batman can only rescue one ( opportunity cost ). If theres any consolation to be had in the alternate universe where Rachel Dawes survived The Dark Knights ultimate coin toss, itd be the act that her potential heel would have opened a brand new path to revenge. But heres the thing: Batman was never designed to work completely alone in the first place. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. But in order to maintain that level of endearment, those moments have to be executed precisely. What was Jim Gordon's original plan and who else was involved in it? Hello and welcome to Scifi.SE! Joker tells Batman that Harvey is at 250 52nd Street and that Rachel is on Avenue X, the female cop calls Gordon's wife and tells her to go to 250 52nd Street. Rachel Dies Giving Birth - Jacob and his group left Bethel. Rachel was very clearly conscious the entire time whereas Harvey was unconscious and woke up to her yelling. Knight. Looking at the chain of events that occur in both scenarios, the path of The Dark Knight and The Dark Knight Rises leads to another, greater question about Rachel Dawes and Harvey Dents fates: does it really matter who Batman saves in The Dark Knight? Rachel was disappointed that Bruce would let Dent take the fall for him, and gave Alfred a letter to be delivered to Bruce "when the time is right." After Bruce's parents were murdered by Joe Chill, Rachel's mother sought other employment and left Wayne Manor with Rachel.[1]. Gordon doesn't have a Batman motorcycle, so he arrives too late to save Rachel. The Dark Knight saw the demise of Rachel Dawes after the Joker tricked Batman and the police and only let them save Harvey Dent or her. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. New with box: A brand-new, unused, and unworn item (including handmade items) in the original packaging (such as the original box or bag) and/or with the original tags attached. Study now. It is undeniable that Rachel's character was very important to that particular universe, due to her association with Bruce as well as Harvey Dent as they worked to stop the Joker and the rest of Gotham's organized crime network. Not very clever to chance Rachel's death, if Batman loved her. Batman arrives at Dent's location in time to save him, but Gordon arrives at the other too late, and Rachel dies when the building explodes. He can be found on all social media platforms @sheamus_oneill. Because Christopher Nolans Bat-sequel gave us lots to talk about. Rachel is mentioned several times throughout The Dark Knight Rises. He fights for The User. He serves as the secondary antagonist of The Dark Knight and a posthumous antagonist of The Dark Knight Rises. At one point, the Joker (Heath Ledger) attacks Rachel at Dent's fundraiser, holding her at knifepoint. She was in great pain. At the funeral, the Joker attempts to assassinate Mayor Anthony Garcia (Nestor Carbonell), and leaves behind evidence indicating that Rachel will be next. Rachel takes shelter in Bruce's penthouse at Dent's insistence, and she and Bruce briefly rekindle their romance. If you look at the address clearly, its 50 50 meaning half and half. He then sedated her and had his butler, Alfred Pennyworth, take her home. Thanks. Batman chooses to save Rachel, while Commissioner Jim Gordon (Gary Oldman) moves to save who he thinks is Harvey. he even confesses the truth about Rachel to get Bruce to move on from his past . At the end Alfred just imagines Bruce Wayne in the cafe with Selina Kyle aka Catwoman. Eight years after her death, Bruce kept a picture of her in Wayne Manor. Everything was worked out in due time, and the character, as well as the film, went on full steam ahead without Holmes, for better or worse. As is generally the case in Hollywood, creative differences or frustration between a cast member and the director can tend to result in actors leaving a project. Understanding as ever, he has said "these things happen, and I was very, very fortunate that Maggie [Gyllenhaal] was able to take it over." Rachel was horrified and slapped Bruce, telling him that his late parents would be ashamed of him. Both Rachel and Dent are tied up in rooms surrounded with gasoline drums and remote-controlled explosives, with phones attached so they can talk to each other. By July 2008, Rachel was in a relationship with newly selected District Attorney Harvey Dent, creating a love triangle between him, herself, and Bruce Wayne. Start for FREE. Letter of recommendation contains wrong name of journal, how will this hurt my application? [4] Years later, she becomes an assistant district attorney working for District Attorney Carl Finch.[1]. In an attempt to stop him, Alfred finally confessed to Bruce that Rachel chose Dent and that he burned the letter in order to spare Bruce pain. Batman should always be allowed to fail. Three years later, the sequel titled The Dark Knight was released, and it became not only the best in Nolans Batman trilogy but also one of the best superhero films ever made. In the Dark Knight, why did Batman choose to save Harvey Dent, rather than Rachel Dawes? Hes the only person who can save the day here and there are no other vigilantes, sidekicks or otherwise, who can step in to make things right. Even though Batman was the centerpiece of the trilogy, Rachel Dawes was a welcome addition to the Batman canon and was portrayed by two of Hollywood's best at the time. The Dark Knight is based on a script co-written by London-born screenwriters and brothers Christopher and Jonathan Nolan, from a story by Christopher Nolan and David S. Goyer (co-writer of Batman Begins). So, why wasn't Katie Holmes in The Dark Knightas Rachel Dawes? 4. The Nolan-verse clearly did not agree with the age old adage that Batman needs a Robin. But it certainly would have done well to consider it. Right before she died, Rachel wanted to say something to Harvey, but she wasnt able to finish so what were those last words going to be? Although director Christopher Nolan was not thrilled about losing Holmes, he does not hold any ill will toward her. Upon Rachel's death, Alfred reads her note (which she deliberately left unsealed) in which she reveals that she intends to marry Dent. By setting up the death trap as a binary choice, the Joker assumes the only person in the whole of Gotham City competent enough to make it to one or the other on time is Batman and hes absolutely right. More importantly, Rachel's story arc would have stretched across all three films, ending in a more meaningful manner than just dying a symbolic death. In the Harvey/Rachel plot in The Dark Knight, there are two reasons why Bruce fails. Theres no explanation given for why the GCPD doesnt make it to Rachel on time, despite having left the station in the same moment as Bruce and, presumably, having units closer to the scene they could have radioed in. and that if he does not, people will die. Soon afterward, Bruce leaves the United States and Rachel continues her studies in law school. She wakes up in her bed and delivers samples of an anti-toxin to Gotham City Police Department sergeant James Gordon (Gary Oldman). Could Rachel Amber have killed herself? Additionally, a picture of her appears in Wayne Manor (Maggie Gyllenhaals archival portrayal of the character in The Dark Knight only). She explains that while Gotham may come to no longer need Batman, she now knows that the day when Bruce no longer does will never come. A dark knight." - James Gordon. Using a Counter to Select Range, Delete, and Shift Row Up, First story where the hero/MC trains a defenseless village against raiders, Poisson regression with constraint on the coefficients of two variables be the same. In turn, Jim Gordon is sent to save Rachel Dawes, but as this is a brilliant Catch-22 scenario, Bruce Wayne actually saves Rachel, leaving Harvey to die in a fire. James Sheridan is right here. The first trailer for WB Games Montreal's Gotham Knights confirmed . Guillermo del Toro said hi to her once. At the end RELATED:Zack Snyder's Justice League Cut Includes A New Robin Easter Egg. After an intense interrogation session, The Joker tells Batman/Bruce Wayne that both Harvey Dent and Rachel Dawes have been kidnapped, and are just minutes away from dying in an explosion. 53 minutes into the film, it appears as if Batman leaves party guests at the mercy of the Joker when he dives out a window to save Rachel's life. Katie Holmes was to reprise as Rachel in The Dark Knight, but turned it down in order to star in Mad Money instead. Answer (1 of 22): Easy. She and Bruce share a kiss, but she tells him that they cannot be together until Gotham no longer needs Batman, now fully aware of his secret. [1], After the incident in the Narrows, Rachel visited the remains of Wayne Manor, finding Bruce and Alfred sorting through the wreckage. Few are likely toquestion Katie Holmes' departure from Nolan'sBatman franchisemore than Katie Holmes herself, as Mad Money faceplanted critically and commercially. Glad I found this sub, need to share an important piece of information about TDKR. Rachel is Bruce Wayne's closest childhood friend. Fortunately, this appears to have been an amicable parting. While it doesn't adapt any one . Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! So,even thoughnaysayers got their wish and Holmes didn't return for The Dark Knight, it had nothing to do with Nolan, and theactor has continued to thrive in Hollywood in the years since. Batman goes to rescue Rachel but the Joker has switched their addresses and he actually ends up rescuing Dent 1. Prior to Screen Rant, she wrote for Pop Wrapped, 4 Your Excitement (4YE), and D20Crit, where she was also a regular guest at Netfreaks podcast. The introduction of Rachel Dawes into the Dark Knight trilogy is strange in the first place, let alone her involvement in the trilogy's second film. Her death is further felt in the final installment of the trilogy, The Dark Knight Rises, as Bruce Wayne continues to mourn her absence. Theres a running gag in which Alfred pointedly reminds Bruce that hes going to have to learn his limits, to which Bruce smirks and reminds him that Batman has none. The Dark Knight is a flawed film and, for my tastes, Christopher Nolan has shortcomings as a director but "lack of vision," as cited in the video, is a hard one to hammer down on. Bruce, having retired from being Batman after taking the blame for Dent's crimes to ensure he is remembered as a hero, is portrayed as still mourning Rachel eight years after her death, rarely leaving Wayne Manor, and not trying to pursue relationships for fear of not being faithful to Rachel. 16Jacob and his group left Bethel. Only, instead of these two threads being told in separate strands, it becomes one gigantic free-for-all where the Caped Crusader isnt safe at all. Will all turbine blades stop moving in the event of a emergency shutdown, Indefinite article before noun starting with "the", Card trick: guessing the suit if you see the remaining three cards (important is that you can't move or turn the cards). This new character somehow got tangled up in . Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy is one of those sets of films that refuses to go out of style or circulation. Frankly? . [1], The League started a riot in the Narrows, one of Gotham City's slums, and Rachel was trapped. So: the Joker definitely told Batman the wrong addresses. She was a member of the Major Crimes Unit. Batman saves them at the last minute and gives Rachel a hint as to his secret identity. She also takes Bruce down to the slums and shows him that Falcone's criminal empire has worsened the poverty created by Gotham's economic depression, and states that every day more people just like Chill turn to crime out of desperation. Thank you for signing up to CinemaBlend. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Here's why. Meanwhile, the GCPD, believing theyre rescuing Harvey, end up making it to Rachel too late. A farmer has 19 sheep All but 7 die How many are left? Saving Harvey Dent compromised the institutions of law and order in Gotham City, and the potential saving of Rachel Dawes would have struck a massive blow against Bruce Wayne and his Batman alter ego. When Bruce Wayne returns as Batman in Dark Knight Rises he isn't the same person in terms of his reaction times and agility which he possessed years ago when he decided to hang up his boots at the end of Dark Knight (plus the limping at the start of the movie). However, the relationship between Rachel and Bruce is probably going to be fractured at this point, and for one big reason. The loss of Rachel, in addition to his own disfigurement, drove Dent insane and after the Joker's convincing, he became the murderous vigilante Two-Face, seeking revenge on those he held responsible for her death. Both Rachel and Dent were tied up in rooms surrounded with gasoline drums and remote-controlled explosives, with phones attached so they could talk to each other. Adrienne Tyler is a features writer for Screen Rant. Initially portrayed by Katie Holmes, the actress did not reprise her role in 2008's The Dark Knight. Soon, the city was overrun by Arkham's inmates, whom the League had released, and Rachel and the boy were surrounded by lunatics led by Falcone's henchman, Victor Zsasz. Rachel was intrigued by the masked crime-fighter, unaware that he was her old friend Bruce. Rachel attended the funeral of police commissioner Gillian Loeb, who was murdered by the Joker. In Nolan's The Dark Knight, when the Joker kidnapped Harvey Dent and Rachel Dawes and trapped them in a weird oil drum showroom: Why did Batman tell Gordon that he was going to save Rachel and they should go for Harvey, but instead it appeared to me they both went for Harvey? In jail, Batman questions the Joker. Rachel Dawes was created for the Nolan Batman universe, first appearing in Batman Begins as the childhood friend and love interest of Bruce Wayne. Years later, she becomes an assistant district attorney working for District Attorney Carl Finch (Larry Holden). Harvey Dents tragic death would only push the stakes up higher, as with Batman being singled out as the guilty party in his death, the city would want blood for the death of its fallen angel. [3] Dent ultimately appeared in the sequel The Dark Knight, portrayed by Aaron Eckhart. Does Rachael die in the film The Dark Knight? Without contrary proof, I believed that. . The Jokers plan to push one of Gothams legal eagles to the edge wins out, as Rachel Dawes becomes unhinged, and dedicates herself to avenging her dearly departed lover. Since she and Bruce were the same age, she was became his playmate. do you go for the girl or the person who is truly important. She dies in the explosion and Dent is left traumatized, scarred its his first real step into his Two-Face persona in this universe and believing Batman made the wrong choice. The Joker gave Batman the address, but the Joker knew they were in opposite location and tricked Batman again. The Batman saved them at the last minute and gave Rachel a hint as to his secret identity. The Joker knew that Batman loved Rachel, so the Joker wanted to inflict mental pain on the Batman by killing Rachel. The Dark Knight: What Was Rachel Going To Say To Harvey Dent? How dry does a rock/metal vocal have to be during recording? At the end of The Dark Knight Rises, when Batman is believed to be dead after saving Gotham, he has earned the respect that he deserves, even getting a statue put up in his honor. Heres how it works. Shortly afterward, Falcone has a psychotic break in police custody, and Rachel believes he is faking it to avoid trial, unaware that Crane drugged him with his fear toxin. RELATED:Joker: How the Man Who Laughs Gave the DC Icon His Secret Origin. The Dark Knight throws a huge ethical curveball that determines the rest of the film, with The Joker (Heath Ledger) forcing Batman to choose who to save from a firey Catch-22: his childhood friend and crush Rachel Dawes (Maggie Gyllenhaal), or Dent, the white knight of Gotham.
Command Indicates Who And What Type Of Authority An Assigned Commander,
Shelby Simmons Bunk'd,
Richie Mo'unga Family,
Articles D